The Carnegie Pulseabout the carnegie pulse | advertise | contact | subscriptions | join 
newsart & cultureopinionseventscourse schedule

home  >  news  >  student senate sparks over diversity issues  >  

   MORE NEWS

  
HCI has a helping Hug
Dec 7 8:11 pm

  
Starring Senators as themselves
Dec 7 8:11 pm

  
Corporate media: "don't believe the hype"
Nov 30 2:36 pm

  
Senators support PAT
Nov 30 11:14 am

  
Carnegie Mellon student wins Jeopardy!
Nov 23 8:01 pm

  
NSF funds new Climate Decision Making Center
Nov 19 10:22 am

  
Charitable angels make holiday wishes possible
Nov 17 2:03 pm

  
Fiscal amendments fail in Senate
Nov 16 9:25 pm

  
Singers recognized for beautiful music
Nov 15 10:45 pm

  
Armed robberies occur near campus
Nov 10 10:23 pm


Student Senate sparks over diversity issues
10.17.04 08:25 pm | by Lindsey Quinn Arroyo

Last week's Student Senate meeting included committee reports and special allocations as usual, but with the bulk of their time, Senators considered the special issue of campus diversity and tolerance.

Suspending their usual "Robert's Rules" code of conduct in favor of what Senate Chair Nicholas Scocozzo called "rules of courtesy," Senators held a free-form discussion on the Report from the Presidential Commission Responding to Issues Raised by the April 2004 Publication of The Natrat. The Report was written by a committee of students, staff, faculty, and an alumnus in response to the controversy surrounding the most recent April Fool's Day edition of The Tartan. Last spring, the "joke" publication garnered local and national headlines when the campus community rallied against its editors for printing material that was offensive to women, minorities, and the GLBT community.

The Report contains recommendations about how The Tartan can restructure and revive its staff following the incident, and also about how the broader campus community can become more sensitive toward issues of diversity and tolerance. Scocozzo asked his fellow senators if and how they believe the Report relates to their own organization.

Though some senators denied thatthe Carnegie Mellon campus lacks sensitivity toward diversity — one first-year senator said the Natrat incident was "blown out of proportion" and its subsequent backlash "sounds like crap" — most agreed that the issue is a pervasive and persistent problem.

Senator Nicolette Louissaint — who sat on the Natrat Committee and alsoconducted extensive interviews with the campus community about diversity — stressed that while the University might boast a statistically diverse constituency, students fail to fully embrace and appreciate their differences.

"I don't see the benefit of being in a place like this if you're not engaged," she said, imploring her peers to examine their surroundings and become more involved in intercultural, interdisciplinary experiences.

Also present for the discussion was Mark Egerman, a fifth-year scholar and the Executive Officer appointed by The Tartan following the Natrat incident. While Egerman concurred with Louissaint's points, he suggested that the diversity issue is a reflection of a larger ethical issue, one borne from Carnegie Mellon's highly specialized academic curriculum. He emphatically charged senators to turn their conceptual discourse into "actionable items," steps that campus organizations and the entire student body can take to rectify their situation.

"As a non-senator, I expect more from you guys," he said. "[You're] glossing over the entire problem."

HSS senator Josh Yearsley proposed creating an ad hoc committee to more thoroughly examine the Natrat Report and develop a specific, tangible plan of action for Senate to follow in promoting diversity awareness and tolerance. Jennifer Parry Bird, the advisor to both Student Senate and The Tartan, supported the idea because it would allow senators to give the issue the time and attention it deserves.

"[We need] to consider deeply each one of these recommendations … and come back to the next meeting with practical solutions," she said.

In other Senate news, the Academic Affairs Committee is looking into implementing an advisor evaluation system to monitor professional advisors' efficacy; the Campus Life Committee is reviewing the campus poster policy and investigating the changes that the Port Authority might be making to their bus lines; and Internal Development reported three Senate vacancies, in CFA, MCS, and SHS/BHA/BSA. Prospective Senators for these seats must submit signed nomination petitions by Tuesday the 19th at 5 pm, to UC Box 46 at the UC Info Desk.

A special allocation of $3,000 was granted to Summit for AB Tech costs. The Men's Athletic Special Interest Housing received $200 towards a Homecoming barbeque and Spirit was given a $175 loan to help them get started on fundraising efforts for victims of hurricanes in Haiti and Jamaica.



talkback to the pulse
No comments have been posted, yet. Be the first to post!
Share your opinion with other Pulse readers. Login below or register to begin posting.

Email address:
Password:



  THE PULSE MESSENGER!
  • Get the latest Pulse stories and events in your email inbox.

    Email address:

  EVENTS    more
  • ICES Seminar Series: Carbon Nanotube Thermal Transport from Molecular Dynamics
    Wed 11:00 am, 1202 Hamburg Hall
  • Mini-Workshop on Wavelets in Bioimaging
    Wed 1:30 pm, Wright Room, UC
  • The Duchess of Malfi
    Wed 7:30 pm, Philip Chosky Theate...
  • "The Wrong Gift," (working title) a play by Mary F. Unser
    Wed 8:00 pm, Purnell Center for t...
  • ULS: Ideas into Action: Success Stories
    Wed 8:30 pm, Adamson Wing, Baker ...
  • Nightmare Before Christmas
    Wed 10:00 pm, McConomy Aud., UC
  • Nightmare Before Christmas
    Thu 12:00 am, McConomy Aud., UC
  • The Duchess of Malfi
    Thu 7:30 pm, Philip Chosky Theate...
  • Challenges of Terrorism and Insurgency in Iraq and Worldwide
    Thu 7:30 pm, Parish Hall of The E...
  • "Fragments of Memory," a play by Lulin Yu
    Thu 8:00 pm, Purnell Center for t...
  MOST READ STORIES
  • Carnegie Mellon student wins Jeopardy!
  • Mr. SigEp named Mr. Fraternity
  • National Treasure not quite precious
  • The eight worst things you can do at the gym
  • When Tyrants Kiss
  • Motion City Soundtrack to play Monday



  email: tcpulse@andrew.cmu.edu     ::     phone: 801.848.4812     ::     fax: 801.848.4812     ::    
  mail: The Carnegie Pulse | Carnegie Mellon University | University Center, Box 78 | Pittsburgh, PA 15213     ::    
  (c) Copyright 2004 The Carnegie Pulse, Carnegie Mellon's first exclusively online student-run news source. campus mirror | RSS