The Nature of Reason

Course 80-150

Fall 2000

 

The following syllabus is tentative, and only a rough outline. Most topics will overlap lectures. You will receive precise reading assignments in the weekly handouts. The syllabus will be posted on http://www.andrew.cmu.edu/~ps7z/syllabus1.html  and the assignments will all be reachable over the internet from the syllabus.

 

Instructor: Peter Spirtes

135D BH

x88460

ps7z@andrew.cmu.edu

Office Hours: M, W: 10:30-12:00, or by appointment

 

Grader: David Meieran

143 BH

x8148

dmeieran@andrew.cmu.edu

Office Hours: T 12:30-1:30, or by appointment

 

Textbooks: Thinking Things Through by Clark Glymour

                    Classics Of Western Philosophy, ed. by Cahn

 

Grading: 33% homework, 33% midterm, 33% final

 

 

Introduction

 

8/28         Monday                 Overview and Example: Euclid’s geometry

                                                Reading:        TTT: Preface, and Chapter 1, pp. 3-15

                                                                        http://www.andrew.cmu.edu/~ps7z/Assignment1.html

 

8/30         Wednesday          Examples: The existence of God, Reasoning about the Infinite

                                                Reading:        TTT: Chapter 1

                                                                        Anselm, excerpts from Proslogion (and Guanilo’s Reply)

                                                                        Aquinas, excerpts from Summa Theologica

                                                                        Spinoza, excerpts from The EthicsAncient Philosophy

 

9/6           Wednesday          Reading:        TTT, Chapter 2, to p. 43

                                                                        Plato, Meno, and excerpts from The Republic

                                                                        http://www.andrew.cmu.edu/~ps7z/Assignment2.html

 

 

Part I: Deductive Logic

 

9/11         Monday                 Aristotle’s theory of logic and science

                                                Reading:        TTT, Chapter 2

                                                                        Aristotle, excerpts from Categories, Physics, and

                                                                        Metaphysics

 

9/13         Wednesday          Ideas and combinations

                                                Reading:        TTT, Chapter 3

                                                                        Hobbes, excerpts from Leviathan

                                                                        http://www.andrew.cmu.edu/~ps7z/Assignment3.html

 

9/18         Monday                 Ideas and combinations

                                                Reading:        TTT, Chapter 3

                                                                        Descartes, excerpts from Meditations on First Philosophy

 

9/20         Wednesday          Ideas and combinations

                                                Reading:        TTT, Chapter 3

                                                                        Leibniz, excerpts from Monadology

 

9/25         Monday                 Boole’s theory of logic

                                                Reading:        TTT, Chapter 4

                                                                        http://www.andrew.cmu.edu/~ps7z/Assignment4.html

 

9/27         Wednesday          Frege’s theory of logic

                                                Reading:        TTT, Chapter 5

 

10/2         Monday                 The rise of the scientific method

                                                Reading:        TTT, Chapter 7

                                                                        http://www.andrew.cmu.edu/~ps7z/Assignment5.html

 

Part II: Inductive Logic

 

10/4         Wednesday          Hume’s skepticism

                                                Reading:        TTT, Chapter 7

                                                                        Hume, excerpts from An Inquiry Concerning Human

 

10/9         Monday                 Understanding Probability

                                                Reading:        TTT, Chapter 8, to page 206

                                                                        http://www.andrew.cmu.edu/~ps7z/Assignment6.html

               

10/11       Wednesday          Bayesian solutions

                                                Reading:        TTT, the rest of Chapter 8

                                                                        http://www.andrew.cmu.edu/~ps7z/study.html

 

10/16       Monday                 (midterm exam)

 

10/18       Wednesday          Understanding Probability

                                                                        http://www.andrew.cmu.edu/~ps7z/prob.pdf

                                                                        http://www.andrew.cmu.edu/~ps7z/time.pdf

 

10/25       Wednesday          Understanding Probability

                                                Reading: Handout

 

10/30       Monday                 Kant

                                                Reading:        TTT, Chapter 9, to page 228

                                                                        Kant, excerpts from Critique of Pure Reason

                                                                        http://www.andrew.cmu.edu/~ps7z/Assignment7.html

 

11/1         Wednesday          Kant

                                                Reading:        TTT, rest of Chapter 9

                                                                        Kant, excerpts from Critique of Pure Reason

 

11/6         Monday                 Modern philosophy of science

                                                Reading:        TTT, Chapter 10 to 266

 

 

Part III: Mind and Computation

 

11/8         Wednesday          Modern philosophy of science

                                                Reading:        TTT, Chapter 10 to 266

 

11/13       Monday                 Theories of mind

                                                Reading:        TTT, Chapter 11

                                                http://www.andrew.cmu.edu/~ps7z/Assignment8.html

 

11/15       Wednesday          Questions about the nature of mind

                                                Reading:        TTT, Chapter 11

 

11/20       Monday                 The theory of computation

                                                Reading:        TTT, Chapter 12

                                                http://www.andrew.cmu.edu/~ps7z/compute.pdf

                                                http://www.andrew.cmu.edu/~ps7z/Assignment9.html

 

11/27       Monday                 Undecidability and incompleteness

                                                Reading:        TTT, Chapter 12

 

11/29       Wednesday          Undecidability and incompleteness

                                                Reading:        TTT, Chapter 12

 

12/4         Monday                 The Computational Theory of Mind

                                                Reading:        TTT, Chapter 13

 

12/6         Wednesday          The Computational Theory of Mind

                                                Reading:        TTT, Chapter 13

 

12/11       Monday                 Summary and Conclusion

                                                Reading:        TTT, Chapter 13

                                                                        http://www.andrew.cmu.edu/~ps7z/study2.html