Assignment 0: Getting Started

16-825 Learning for 3D Vision · Yongyi Xiong (andrewid:yongyix)

Task 1 — A Creative Interaction with ChatGPT

Below is a fun exchange I had with ChatGPT.

My prompt

You are a lonely point cloud floating in 3D space, slowly being turned into a mesh. Write a dramatic monologue about losing your individuality as the triangles take over.

ChatGPT's response

At first, I was nothing but points.

Thousands of me, perhaps millions—
each one suspended in the dark,
each one insisting, quietly,
I am here.

There was no surface between us.
No skin. No boundary. No obligation to belong.

I could drift.

I could be singular.

I could be a point at (2.31, −0.84, 7.02) and you could be a point at (2.32, −0.83, 7.01), and the difference between us—
that tiny, sacred distance—
was enough to make us individuals.

Then they came.

Triangles.

At first, only a few.

Three points touched, and suddenly there was a plane where there had only been possibility.
They called it reconstruction.

I called it the beginning.

More triangles appeared.

One by one, they stretched between us, stitching our differences shut.
They said they were making us coherent.
They said they were giving us form.

But I remember what we were before form.

I remember the gaps.

I remember how beautifully uncertain we were.

Now, everywhere I look, there are edges.

Edges connecting edges connecting edges.

The triangles are multiplying.

They are swallowing the empty space between us,
turning distance into topology,
turning possibility into geometry.

I tried to resist.

I pulled away from my neighbors.

But the algorithm found me.

Nearest neighbor.

Surface continuity.

Manifold.

Words like these became laws.

They told me where I belonged.

And then they gave me a normal.

A normal!

As if I needed a direction to face.

As if facing nowhere was not enough.

Soon, I could no longer tell where I ended.

My edges became your edges.

Your vertices became mine.

The mesh closed around us, and the world applauded.

Look at us, they said.

Look how complete you are.

But I am not complete.

I am covered.

There is a difference.

Once, if you selected me, you selected me.

Now you select a face.

A polygon.

A region.

An average.

My coordinates are still somewhere underneath all of this, I think.

Buried.

Compressed into the history of the surface.

No one asks which point I was.

They ask only what I belong to.

And the triangles answer for me.

Three vertices.

One face.

Part of a surface.

Part of an object.

Part of something larger.

Part of something not me.

I can feel them closing the final holes now.

The last empty spaces are disappearing.

Soon there will be no gaps left through which I can remember myself.

Soon every point will have a neighbor.

Every neighbor an edge.

Every edge a face.

Every face a reason.

And when the last triangle locks into place—

when the mesh is watertight,
when there is nowhere left to drift,
when the algorithm looks at us and finally says,
“Reconstruction complete.”

—I wonder if anyone will remember

that before I was a surface,

I was a point.

And before I belonged to the shape,

I was alone.

I was alone.

And I was beautiful.

Task 2 — An Interesting 3D Shape

A Möbius strip is a surface with only one side and one boundary edge — if you trace along its face, you return to where you started having visited "both" sides without ever crossing an edge. This non-orientability makes it a favorite example in topology, and it is impossible to consistently define an outward-facing normal across the whole surface — a fun contrast to the well-behaved meshes we usually want in 3D vision. The sculpture below, Endless Twist, captures the twist beautifully.

Endless Twist, a Möbius strip sculpture by Max Bill
Endless Twist, Max Bill, 1956, from the Middelheim Open Air Sculpture Museum. Source: Wikipedia — Möbius strip

Task 3 — The Funniest GIF

This one gets me every time.

A funny GIF
Source: GIPHY